Best Refrigerators With Ice Makers

The best refrigerator with an ice maker for most households is the BLACK+DECKER 24 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator with Ice Maker (BR2400JIMW). It combines a 24-cubic-foot top-mount layout with a factory-installed freezer ice maker, so you get ice without gambling on whether an aftermarket module will fit a fridge you already own. It suits families who want the most storage per dollar, a simple two-door design, and an ice maker that lives in the freezer compartment — the easiest place to reach when something eventually needs service.

That said, a large share of people searching for the best refrigerator with an ice maker already own a refrigerator. If yours is otherwise healthy and only the ice maker has failed, replacing the assembly is almost always the better decision than buying a new appliance: a matched replacement module costs a fraction of a new refrigerator and typically installs in 20 to 60 minutes with basic hand tools. This guide covers both paths — the one complete refrigerator on the list, and the seven components that keep an existing ice maker producing ice for years.

Top 3 Picks

Best overall: BLACK+DECKER 24 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator with Ice Maker (BR2400JIMW)

The only complete appliance here, and the only pick that solves the problem end to end. Twenty-four cubic feet in a top-mount body gives you more usable capacity per dollar than any French-door layout, and because the ice maker sits in the freezer rather than behind a door panel, both production and service access are simpler. Best for buyers replacing a whole refrigerator rather than repairing one.

Best budget: Nurfosttek 241798224 / 241798231 Ice Maker

If your Frigidaire-built refrigerator stopped making ice, this is the cheapest reliable route back to working cubes. It cross-references the two most common Frigidaire ice maker part numbers, which means a single purchase covers a wide spread of Electrolux-family models. Best for owners of older Frigidaire, Kenmore, Gibson, Tappan, or White-Westinghouse side-by-sides who want to spend as little as possible.

Best premium: ZAL W10882923 / W10377151 Ice Maker Replacement

The most expensive component on this list, and for a reason: Whirlpool’s French-door ice maker is a more complex assembly than the simple freezer-mounted units, and a cheaply built aftermarket version will show its weaknesses quickly in a high-cycle household. Best for Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, or JennAir owners who want the most robust aftermarket build available and are willing to pay for it.

Quick Comparison

Every product below, sorted by what it actually solves. Price tiers are relative bands, not fixed figures — component pricing moves constantly and varies by seller.

How We Chose

This is a research-based roundup. We did not test, benchmark, disassemble, or handle any of these products, and nothing here reflects hands-on experience. Every specification comes from the manufacturer’s stated product information or the listing itself, and every claim about fitment comes from the part numbers the listing cross-references.

Four criteria drove the picks. First, fitment clarity: a replacement ice maker is only useful if you can confirm it matches your model, so we favored products that list the specific part numbers they replace rather than vague “fits most” language. Second, category fit: this list deliberately spans two different jobs — buying a refrigerator and repairing one — because those are the two things people mean when they search this topic. Third, OEM versus aftermarket value: genuine parts cost more and remove fitment risk, while aftermarket parts save money and are often the only option for older appliances. We flagged which is which rather than pretending one always wins. Fourth, upgrade path: a new ice maker on a failing refrigerator is wasted money, so the guide includes a repair-versus-replace decision framework and a filtration upgrade that extends the life of whatever ice maker you install.

1. BLACK+DECKER BR2400JIMW 24 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator – Best for Replacing a Whole Fridge

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

#1 Pick

BLACK+DECKER 24 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator with Ice Maker, BR2400JIMW

Check Price on Amazon →

This is the only complete refrigerator on the list, and it is the pick for anyone whose current appliance has failed badly enough that repair no longer makes sense — a dead compressor, a sealed system leak, a rusted-out cabinet, or simply a 15-year-old unit that costs more to run than a modern one. It also suits first-time buyers furnishing a kitchen who want an ice maker without paying French-door prices.

The appeal is the layout. Top-mount refrigerators put the freezer above the fresh-food section, which means the ice maker lives inside the freezer — a mechanically simpler position than an in-door ice room. There is no dispenser motor to fail, no door-mounted auger, no cavity in the door stealing usable shelf space. When the ice maker eventually needs attention, you open the freezer and work in the open.

Key specs

• Total capacity: 24 cubic feet, stated in the model name
• Configuration: top-mount, freestanding, two doors
• Ice maker: factory-installed, freezer compartment
• Water supply: requires a cold-water line run to the refrigerator
• Dispenser: none through the door; ice is retrieved from the freezer bin
• Finish: white class (the W suffix in this line conventionally denotes white — confirm against the product page)
• Footprint class: a 24 cu ft top-mount typically sits in the 30 to 33 inch width band and stands roughly 66 to 70 inches tall; verify exact dimensions, since they vary by model

Strengths

The capacity-per-dollar math is the strongest argument. Twenty-four cubic feet is genuinely generous, and because the design carries no through-the-door dispenser, essentially all of that volume is usable storage rather than machinery housing. For a household that buys in bulk, that difference is felt every grocery run.

The second strength is serviceability. A freezer-mounted ice maker is the least complicated ice maker architecture in production: a fill cup, a mold with a heater, a motor-driven ejector, a shutoff arm or sensor, and a short harness. Fewer parts and no door routing mean fewer failure points and cheaper repairs down the line. The freezer environment is also consistently cold, so the ice maker is not fighting warm-room air the way some in-door units do.

Third, filtration is flexible. With no built-in filter housing to feed, you can run an inline cartridge on the water line behind the refrigerator and change it on your own schedule — which is where the AQUA CREST filter later in this list fits naturally.

Pros

• 24 cu ft of capacity in a layout that wastes almost nothing on dispensing hardware
• Factory ice maker eliminates all aftermarket fitment risk
• Simplest ice maker architecture available, which means cheaper future repairs
• No in-door dispenser motor, auger, or door cavity to fail or freeze
• Accepts any inline 1/4-inch water filter, so filtration is your choice rather than a proprietary cartridge

Cons

• No through-the-door ice or water dispenser — every cube requires opening the freezer
• Top-mount ergonomics put frozen goods above eye level and fresh food below
• Single freezer and single fresh-food zone, so no independent temperature control between compartments
• Ice storage bin is a modest freezer tray rather than a large in-door bin
• White finish limits how well it blends into darker kitchen designs

How it compares

Compared with every other product here, this is the only one that solves the problem by replacing the appliance rather than a component. If your existing refrigerator is fundamentally sound, buying this instead of a replacement ice maker is spending twenty to fifty times more to fix the same complaint — the Samsung, Frigidaire, ZAL, Nurfosttek, REE.PLAR, and Mintu modules exist precisely so you do not have to do that. The crossover point is when the refrigerator itself is failing: multiple system faults, a sealed-system repair quote, or an age past roughly 12 to 15 years, at which point component spending stops being an investment.

2. Samsung DA97-15217D Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly – Best for Genuine Samsung Repair

#2 Pick

Samsung DA97-15217D Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly (Replaces DA97-15217A) Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part

Check Price on Amazon →

This is the pick for Samsung French-door owners who want the manufacturer’s own part rather than an aftermarket copy. It suits anyone who has already replaced a cheap ice maker once and does not want to repeat the exercise, and anyone whose refrigerator is still under a service plan or recent enough that matching the original specification matters.

The listing identifies it as genuine original equipment, and it cross-references DA97-15217A as the part it supersedes. That cross-reference matters: Samsung’s ice maker part numbers have been revised over the product life of the models that use them, so a listing that names both the current and the superseded number is giving you the information you need to confirm fitment before you buy.

Key specs

• Type: genuine OEM ice maker assembly
• Replaces: DA97-15217A and the part numbers it supersedes
• Fitment class: Samsung French-door refrigerators with a freezer-compartment or ice-room ice maker
• Contents: complete ice maker module — mold, ejector mechanism, heater, fill cup and connector harness class
• Installation: direct replacement of the failed module; no cabinet modification required

Strengths

The core advantage is fitment certainty. Aftermarket ice makers are dimensioned to work across a family of models, and small tolerance differences in the fill cup, mounting tabs, or connector pinout are exactly where installation problems show up. A genuine part is built to the same drawing as the one that came out of your refrigerator, so the fill cup aligns with the water inlet and the harness plugs in without adaptation.

The second advantage is the integrated heater and thermistor. Ice makers in this class rely on a short heating cycle to release cubes from the mold and on temperature sensing to decide when to harvest. When an aftermarket unit’s heater is underpowered or its sensing is off, you get the classic symptoms: cubes that stick, partial harvests, or a mold that slowly ices over until production stops. Matching the original specification is the most direct way to avoid that.

Third, it is a genuinely repairable part. If your refrigerator is otherwise healthy — compressor running normally, temperatures stable, no error codes beyond the ice maker — a new OEM module restores the full function of the appliance for a mid-range outlay, and the rest of the refrigerator keeps working exactly as before.

Pros

• Genuine OEM part, so fitment and connector compatibility are as close to guaranteed as they get
• Explicitly cross-references the superseded DA97-15217A number, making fitment checks straightforward
• Integrated heater and sensing match the original specification, which reduces recurring freeze-up symptoms
• Direct-swap installation on a compatible model, typically a short job with basic tools
• Restores full ice production without replacing a working refrigerator

Cons

• Genuine OEM pricing is higher than aftermarket equivalents for the same function
• Fitment is narrow by design — it is not a universal part, so you must confirm your model
• It fixes the ice maker only; if the underlying cause is a failing water inlet valve or a kinked line, the new module will not solve it
• Samsung ice maker compartments have a well-documented reputation for freeze-up issues across the category, so airflow and door-seal health still matter after installation

How it compares

The nearest alternative in this list is the ZAL Whirlpool replacement, which occupies a similar premium position but for a different brand family — the two are not interchangeable, and your refrigerator’s brand decides which one applies. Against the budget Frigidaire-family modules (Nurfosttek and REE.PLAR), this Samsung part costs more but removes the fitment guesswork entirely, which is the right trade for a newer refrigerator and the wrong trade for a fifteen-year-old one. If your Samsung is under roughly eight years old and mechanically sound, the OEM module is the better long-term purchase.

3. Frigidaire IM116000 Ice Maker Assembly Kit – Best for Frigidaire and Electrolux Owners

#3 Pick

Frigidaire IM116000 Ice Maker Assembly Kit for Refrigerators, White

Check Price on Amazon →

This is the OEM answer for Frigidaire-built refrigerators, and it covers a broader range of configurations than the brand-specific Samsung part — top-mounts, side-by-sides, and the Electrolux-family models that share the platform. It suits owners who want the manufacturer’s part and are willing to pay mid-range money to avoid a fitment gamble.

The listing describes it as an assembly kit in white, which is the practical detail most people miss: a white ice maker front matches the interior trim of the freezer or ice room on the models it fits, while a mismatched finish is a small but permanent annoyance on an appliance you look at every day.

Key specs

• Type: OEM ice maker assembly kit
• Finish: white
• Fitment class: Frigidaire and Electrolux-family refrigerators, including top-mount and side-by-side configurations
• Contents: ice maker assembly plus mounting hardware and fill cup class components
• Installation: direct replacement in the freezer or ice room; mounting pattern matches the original

Strengths

The word “kit” is doing real work here. Ice maker replacements frequently stall because a bracket, screw set, or fill cup from the old unit does not transfer cleanly to the new one, or because the old hardware is corroded and breaks on removal. A kit that includes the mounting hardware removes that failure mode from the job.

Brand coverage is the second strength. Frigidaire’s ice maker platform was shared across Electrolux, Kenmore, Gibson, Tappan, and White-Westinghouse badges for years, which means a single OEM part number can serve a very large installed base. If you own one of those refrigerators and the ice maker has quit, this is the lowest-risk purchase in the category.

Third, OEM white matches the interior. On a side-by-side where the ice maker is visible every time you open the freezer door, an off-color aftermarket module is the kind of detail that quietly bothers you for a decade.

Pros

• OEM part for a wide spread of Frigidaire and Electrolux-family refrigerators
• Kit format includes mounting hardware, so you are not reusing corroded brackets
• White finish matches the original interior trim
• Straightforward direct-swap installation on compatible models
• Covers multiple configurations rather than a single model line

Cons

• Costs meaningfully more than the budget aftermarket modules that fit the same family
• Still requires model verification — “Frigidaire” alone is not enough to guarantee fitment
• Not a universal part, and it will not fit Samsung, Whirlpool, or LG platforms
• If your refrigerator uses a different Frigidaire ice maker revision, you may need a different part number

How it compares

The direct comparison is against the Nurfosttek and REE.PLAR modules, which target the same Frigidaire and Electrolux family at budget pricing. The trade is straightforward: this kit costs more and buys you OEM fitment and included hardware; the budget modules cost less and require you to verify the part number more carefully and reuse your existing brackets. For a refrigerator you plan to keep five or more years, the OEM kit is usually the better economics. For a secondary unit in a garage or a rental property, the budget module is the rational choice.

4. AQUA CREST INL 5-Year Inline Water Filter – Best for Cleaner-Tasting Ice on a Budget

#4 Pick

AQUA CREST INL 5 Years Inline Water Filter for Ice Maker and Refrigerator

Check Price on Amazon →

This is the cheapest meaningful upgrade on the list, and it solves a different problem than everything else here. It suits anyone whose ice maker works fine but whose cubes taste off, look cloudy, or carry a faint odor — and anyone whose refrigerator has no built-in filter housing at all, which includes the top-mount pick above.

The listing names a five-year service interval, which is the headline number. That is an unusually long replacement cycle for refrigerator filtration, and it changes the economics of ice production in a way most buyers never calculate. An inline cartridge of this type mounts on the water line behind or beside the refrigerator and feeds the ice maker directly.

Key specs

• Type: inline water filter for ice makers and refrigerators
• Connection class: 1/4-inch quick-connect fittings, the standard ice maker line size
• Service interval: five years, as stated in the listing name
• Filtration class: carbon block, targeting chlorine, sediment, and taste and odor compounds
• Mounting: inline on the supply line, typically secured to a cabinet wall or the refrigerator frame

Strengths

The first advantage is bypassing proprietary cartridges. Refrigerators with built-in filter housings lock you into a specific cartridge at a specific price, and the housings themselves are a known failure point — cracked heads and leaking O-rings are common. An inline filter installed on the line ahead of the refrigerator delivers comparable basic filtration without the proprietary lock-in, and it works on refrigerators that never had a filter at all.

The second advantage is the replacement interval. Most refrigerator cartridges are rated for roughly six months, which means two changes a year, every year. A five-year inline cartridge reduces that to a single change over the life of several refrigerator filter cycles, and because it is mounted on the line rather than inside the cabinet, changing it does not involve emptying shelves or wrestling a housing in a tight space.

Third, it directly improves ice quality. Cloudy or bad-tasting cubes are usually a dissolved-solids and chlorine issue rather than an ice maker fault, and carbon filtration on the supply line is the correct fix. It also protects the ice maker’s fill valve and mold from sediment buildup over time.

Pros

• Very low entry cost relative to any other product on this list
• Five-year service interval per the listing, versus roughly six months for typical in-fridge cartridges
• Works on refrigerators with no built-in filter housing, including the BLACK+DECKER top-mount
• Removes the proprietary cartridge lock-in that drives up long-term ownership cost
• Protects the ice maker fill valve from sediment

Cons

• Does nothing for a failed ice maker — it is a water quality product, not a repair part
• Requires cutting into or adapting the existing water line, which is more work than swapping a cartridge
• Carbon block filtration of this class does not remove dissolved minerals, so very hard water still produces cloudy ice
• A leak at the fittings is possible if the connection is not seated properly
• Five-year ratings assume typical municipal water quality, not heavy sediment

How it compares

There is no true like-for-like alternative in this list, which is the point — it is the only product here that addresses ice quality rather than ice production. The nearest functional comparison is the BLACK+DECKER refrigerator’s own lack of a built-in filter: pairing that appliance with this inline cartridge gives you filtered ice and water without paying for a filtered-door model. Against the replacement ice makers, it is complementary rather than competitive. If your ice tastes bad and your ice maker works, buy this. If your ice maker does not work, buy a module first and add this afterward.

5. ZAL W10882923 / W10377151 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement – Best Premium Whirlpool Replacement

#5 Pick

Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement for Whirlpool W10882923 W10377151 Compatible with Wrx735Sdbe00 Wrx735Sdbh00 Wrx735Sdbm00

Check Price on Amazon →

This is the premium aftermarket pick, and it targets a specific and demanding job: replacing the ice maker in a Whirlpool French-door refrigerator. It suits owners of the WRX735SDBE00 and WRX735SDBH00 model class, and more broadly anyone with a Whirlpool-built French door whose in-door or ice-room maker has failed and who wants the most robust aftermarket build available.

The listing cross-references two Whirlpool part numbers — W10882923 and W10377151 — which is a meaningful signal. Those numbers represent revisions across the same fitment family, so a single product covering both is built to serve a range of production years rather than one narrow build window.

Key specs

• Type: aftermarket ice maker replacement assembly
• Replaces: W10882923 and W10377151
• Compatible model class: WRX735SDBE00, WRX735SDBH00 and related Whirlpool French-door models
• Construction class: full assembly with mold, ejector, heater and connector harness
• Installation: direct replacement within the ice compartment; no cabinet modification

Strengths

French-door ice makers are harder to build well than freezer-mounted ones. They typically sit in a dedicated ice room or door cavity where airflow is tighter, ambient temperatures fluctuate more, and the assembly has to be compact. That environment punishes thin plastics and weak heaters, which is why cheap aftermarket French-door modules have a reputation for short service lives. A premium-priced replacement is, in this specific category, usually money well spent.

The dual part-number coverage is the second strength. Whirlpool revised these ice makers over the production life of the model families that use them, and a replacement that names both W10882923 and W10377151 is positioned to fit more production years than one that names only the current number. That reduces the chance of ordering a part that physically installs but does not match your harness or mounting pattern.

Third, it is the correct economic answer for a modern French-door refrigerator. A Whirlpool French door in good condition is a significant appliance, and a premium replacement module is a small fraction of replacing it. When the alternative is a several-thousand-dollar purchase, paying more for the better aftermarket part is not a splurge — it is risk management.

Pros

• Premium build targeted at the demanding French-door ice room environment
• Cross-references two Whirlpool part numbers, covering more production years
• Explicitly lists compatible model numbers, making fitment verification practical
• Direct replacement without cabinet or harness modification
• Preserves a working French-door refrigerator at a fraction of replacement cost

Cons

• Highest component price on this list by a wide margin
• Aftermarket, not OEM — so it carries some fitment risk that a genuine Whirlpool part would not
• Narrow fitment: it is not a universal part and will not serve Samsung, LG, or Frigidaire platforms
• Installation in a door-mounted ice room is more awkward than a freezer-mounted swap
• Premium pricing is only justified if the rest of the refrigerator is healthy

How it compares

The nearest alternative is the Mintu W10300022 module, which also serves Whirlpool-family refrigerators at mid-range pricing. The difference is which part number family your refrigerator uses and how much you value the premium build: Mintu covers the W10300022 fitment, while ZAL covers the W10882923 and W10377151 fitment. They are not substitutes for each other — check your model’s part number before choosing. If you land in the ZAL fitment family and your refrigerator is a recent French door you intend to keep, the premium price is defensible. If it is an older side-by-side, the Mintu path is the better value.

6. Nurfosttek 241798224 / 241798231 Ice Maker – Best Budget Frigidaire and Kenmore Replacement

#6 Pick

241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker, Fit for Frigidaire, Kenmore

Check Price on Amazon →

This is the value pick for the Frigidaire-built refrigerator universe, and it exists because OEM parts for older appliances often cost more than the appliance is worth to repair. It suits owners of Frigidaire, Kenmore, and related Electrolux-family refrigerators who want working ice at the lowest possible cost.

The two part numbers in the listing name — 241798224 and 241798231 — are among the most widely used Frigidaire ice maker references, which gives this module unusually broad coverage for a single purchase. If your refrigerator’s ice maker cross-references either number, this is a candidate.

Key specs

• Type: aftermarket ice maker replacement
• Replaces: 241798224 and 241798231
• Fitment class: Frigidaire, Kenmore and Electrolux-family refrigerators
• Construction class: complete assembly with mold, ejector mechanism, heater and fill cup
• Installation: direct replacement in the freezer or ice compartment

Strengths

Price is the entire proposition, and it is a strong one. When a refrigerator is a decade old and the OEM ice maker costs several times what this module does, the budget replacement is the rational call — even accounting for a somewhat shorter service life, you are still ahead. For a garage refrigerator, a rental unit, or a second kitchen, that math is not close.

Coverage is the second strength. Naming two part numbers rather than one doubles the odds that a given buyer’s refrigerator is in scope, and it reflects the reality that Frigidaire’s platform was shared across badges for years. A buyer who is not certain which revision their refrigerator uses has a better chance of landing on a correct part here than with a single-number listing.

Third, the underlying architecture is simple. Frigidaire’s freezer-mounted ice maker design is one of the more straightforward in the industry, which means an aftermarket copy has fewer places to go wrong than a copy of a complex French-door assembly. This is the category where budget parts perform most credibly.

Pros

• Lowest-cost path to working ice in the Frigidaire and Kenmore family
• Two part numbers covered, widening fitment odds
• Simple freezer-mounted architecture that aftermarket copies handle well
• Direct replacement without cabinet modification
• Makes economic sense on older appliances where OEM pricing does not

Cons

• Aftermarket build quality is not guaranteed to match OEM over a long service life
• Mounting hardware and brackets are typically reused from the failed unit, which can be a problem if they are corroded
• No finish or trim details specified beyond the assembly itself
• Will not fit Samsung, Whirlpool, LG, or GE platforms
• Fitment still requires confirming your specific model cross-references one of the two numbers

How it compares

The closest alternative is the REE.PLAR module, which covers the same two part numbers plus 241798211 — one additional reference that may matter if your refrigerator uses that revision. Both are budget-tier. The choice between them comes down to which part numbers your refrigerator’s documentation lists: if 241798211 appears anywhere in your cross-reference, REE.PLAR is the safer pick; if only 241798224 and 241798231 appear, either works and price decides. Against the Frigidaire OEM kit, this is roughly the same job for meaningfully less money, with the tradeoff being long-term build quality.

7. REE.PLAR 241798231 / 241798224 / 241798211 Ice Maker – Best Budget Alternative in the Same Fitment Family

#7 Pick

241798231 241798224 241798211 Ice Maker Replacement, Compatible with Frigidaire Electrolux Kenmore Refrigerators, Replaces 241642511, 241642501 and 241798201 Ice Maker Assembly (Not Universal)

Check Price on Amazon →

This occupies the same budget slot as the Nurfosttek module but casts a slightly wider net. It suits Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore owners who want the broadest part-number coverage in the budget tier, and it is the better pick for anyone whose refrigerator documentation references 241798211.

Three part numbers in one listing is the distinguishing feature. In a category where fitment mistakes are the single most common cause of a failed repair, a wider cross-reference list is not marketing filler — it is the difference between a part that installs and one that does not.

Key specs

• Type: aftermarket ice maker replacement
• Replaces: 241798231, 241798224 and 241798211
• Fitment class: Frigidaire, Electrolux and Kenmore refrigerators
• Construction class: complete assembly with mold, ejector, heater and fill cup
• Installation: direct replacement in the freezer or ice compartment

Strengths

The three-number cross-reference is the primary advantage. Part number 241798211 shows up on certain production runs that the two-number listings do not explicitly cover, and buyers who have been burned by a “close enough” part tend to value that specificity highly.

Second, the same architectural advantage applies as with the Nurfosttek module: this is a straightforward freezer-mounted design, which is the most forgiving category for aftermarket manufacturing. The mechanisms involved — a fill cup, a mold with a release heater, an ejector driven by a small motor, and a shutoff arm — have been built to essentially the